Find information about jury service in this county. For each parcel of taxable real estate, these tax rates will be multiplied by each parcel's listed and assessed valuation as of January 1 and the product of this multiplication is that year's tax bill on the parcel. Find Bank Foreclosures and premium information on Zillow for FREE! Q: What does Durham County do with delinquent tax bills? Bankruptcy proceedings filed by the property owner under federal law can also stop tax foreclosures, but all the taxes, interest, fees and costs of the action to the date of the bankruptcy filing must be paid as a priority claim in the bankruptcy proceeding. Find and bid on Residential Real Estate in Durham County, NC. Family Court Administration. All our foreclosure listings are pre-screened for accuracy by our team of professionals on a daily basis. HUD offers a variety of apartments, duplexes, townhouses and single-family houses to purchase in Durham County, NC. Q: Can the tax foreclosure sale be stopped or redeemed from sale? The information posted here about any tax foreclosure sale property (notice, minimum bid, redemption, structures and pictures) is for assistance only in this investigative process, and cannot and should not be relied upon solely by any bidder. Get peer reviews and client ratings averaging 3.3 of 5.0. Date: February 9, 2021
Q: Why are delinquent real property taxes subject to foreclosure? HUD Homes >> North Carolina >> Durham County HUD Homes . Durham Bank Owned Homes for Sale. After that, the sale stands open for 10 days for possible increased upset bids. We provide nationwide foreclosure listings of pre foreclosures, foreclosed homes , short sales, bank owned homes and sheriff sales. This page lists properties being handled by our office which are scheduled for monthly tax and/or city lien foreclosure sales. Amazing Deals on Foreclosures in Durham County, NC. Click "VIEW" for each property to see additional real estate information about it. Durham, NC 27703 Durham County : Details: Map: 09-02-20. The process is the same when upset bids are received, except that the final high bidder after upset bids are completed is notified to bring in the purchase price of the final high upset bid. The information, pictures, maps, or any other data contained on this website contains no warranties or guarantees. Townhome. Jury Service. Once no upset bids are received during a 10-day period, the attorney notifies the final high bidder that he/she has won, and that they must come up with the balance of the purchase price within three business days. A: Once the Durham Tax Office assigns properties to attorneys to foreclose, the Tax Office marks its computer records with the assignment, and will no longer accept direct payments or payment plans from taxpayers. The County of Durham will enter a minimum starting bid at each property tax foreclosure sale, while the City of Durham will enter a minimum starting bid for each property at a city lien and/or assessment foreclosure sale. Durham, NC Foreclosures - foreclosure listings, preforeclosure, bankruptcy homes, include HUD foreclosures VA foreclosures government foreclosures bank foreclosures Q: What is the legal effect of a tax foreclosure filing? On the second Tuesday of each month, at noon, we conduct the Tax Foreclosure Sale for the County of Durham (see link below). A: It is up to the individual to check the status of the property before bidding. Durham County Department of Public Health Launches COVID-19 Vaccine Data Dashboard BOCC Regular Session Highlights from February 8th Puntos destacados de la sesión ordinaria de la Junta de comisionados del Condado de Durham del 8 de febrero Once a judgment of sale is entered, the property is scheduled for sale at the Durham County Judicial Building. In this case, the attorney will contact the original bidder to let them know their bid was upset. A: Sales are held on the second Tuesday of every month at 12:00pm, Q: Where are the foreclosure sales held? Find foreclosures and foreclosed homes in Durham County, NC. Search 49 Foreclosure Listings in Durham NC, with data on unpaid balances and auction dates. Press Enter to show all options, press Tab go to next option, View Durham County Health Inspection Scores, Find Out About Floodplains and Flooding for my Home or Business, Obtain Copy of Marriage/Birth/Death license/Certificate, Solid Waste, Recycling, and Litter Control, Durham Public Schools Attendance Zone Maps, North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics, Durham County Government Job Opportunities, Durham County Government Holiday Schedule, Property Tax Relief Programs for Builders, More Information About County Owned Surplus Properties, Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about the tax foreclosure process in Durham and in North Carolina (below). A: The sales are held in the lobby of the Durham County Judicial Building, 510 Dillard Street (New Courthouse), Durham, North Carolina. The attorney will then prepare a complaint listing the City and County of Durham as the Plaintiffs (complaining parties). Listing Results Page 1 - 50 of 99. How many HUD foreclosures are available for sale in Durham County, NC? APPRAISER A-460 NC. Property Tax Foreclosure Sale
However, these properties do not belong to the County, and the County does not have access to, and cannot grant access to individuals who wish to enter the properties to check their status. A: You do not have to register for the sale; however, you must be present to bid on a listing. Find out more information about the Durham County Courthouse. Potential bidders should visit the property to determine if it will meet their needs. 2354 NC Foreclosure Rd 2 br 1 ba Active. Durham county, Foreclosures You selected Durham county, Foreclosures. Foreclosure Filings for Durham County, NC The number of new foreclosure filings by foreclosure type. Redemption can even occur after a sale, as long as the sale has not been confirmed by the Court. There are 0 active foreclosures … Sometimes the Tax Office will set up a payment plan with a taxpayer, but the Tax Office is not required to do so, and can terminate payment plans at any time. Foreclosures by the Chatham County Tax Collector’s office are performed by Zacchaeus Legal Services pursuant to North Carolina General Statute §105-374. Back to Full State Foreclosure List Durham, NC Tax Liens and Foreclosure Homes. The Tax Office makes efforts to notify new owners of the existence of tax bills, but state law only requires that the tax bill be sent to the taxpayer as of January 1 of that year, and to the last known address of the taxpayer. Over 1 million foreclosure homes for sale updated daily. Durham County : Details: Map: 09-02-20. If these pre-foreclosure methods still fail, the Tax Office may assign parcels to private attorneys to commence foreclosure proceedings. Sitemap, Shop for Apparel, Tumblers, Hats, and Gifts
Despite the initiation of foreclosure proceedings, the property owner will be given every opportunity to pay the taxes, legal fees and interest to avoid the loss of ownership. A: The Commissioner will make it clear to all bidders present at the public sale that no representation or warranty of any kind is being made about the property or the status of title being delivered. Efforts are made to update this website in a timely manner with redemptions and sale information, but this website cannot be relied upon to be up-to-date in “real time”. The summons and complaint will be delivered to each defendant by the sheriff, or by other approved means of service of process in civil lawsuits (FEDEX, certified mail, process server, etc.). Find the right Durham Co. Foreclosures lawyer from 11 local law firms. Q: What happens the day of the foreclosure sale? Location: 510 Dillard Street (New Courthouse)
A: Properties listed are subject to redemption at any time prior to the entry of a confirmation order by the Court and delivery of a deed by the Commissioner. Each party that is served is clearly informed by the summons that written answer, if any, must be filed with the Court within 30 days from the date the papers were served on the party. Anyone interested in participating in the bidding process should conduct his or her own research for each individual property. Discover foreclosures and foreclosed homes in Durham County, NC. Foreclosures and Foreclosed Homes for Sale in Durham County, NC have a median listing price of $285,000 and a price per square foot of $160. The complaint will be filed in either Durham District or Durham Superior Court (depending on the amount of taxes owed). Over 1 million foreclosure homes for sale updated daily. INSTRUCTIONS: You selected Durham county, NC Foreclosures. A: As noted above, each defendant has 30 days to file a written answer to the complaint if they wish. Once the property tax is delinquent, it is subject to foreclosure prosecution. A: As a general rule, the properties will not be sold subject to any other liens, such as a mortgage. If no upset bids are received, the attorney notifies the high bidder at the sale that the bidder has won, and that bidder has to come up with the balance of the purchase price. At the sale, the highest successful bidder puts up a 10% cash/certified check deposit with the attorney, and the sale is reported to the Clerk of Court. Save up to 60% off with Durham bank foreclosures for sale, pre-foreclosures, short sales and foreclosed home auctions. No representations, warranties or guarantees of any kind are made by the County or Sale Commissioner with respect to these tax foreclosure sales. Persons interested in paying off properties in foreclosure must contact the attorney directly to whom that property was assigned to secure a payoff quote. A: Once the sale is complete, a 10-day upset bid period begins. Founded in 1998. 1 2 Next. For 10 calendar days, the sale stands open for possible increased upset bids. Upset bids of 5% or $750.00, whichever is greater, are received by the Clerk of court for each property. Search our database of Durham County Property Auctions for free! 100% of profits support Triangle Nonprofits. Q: What is the status of title delivered by a tax foreclosure deed? It is the duty of each owner of property to keep the Tax Office notified of address changes and to know that taxes are payable each year, regardless of whether a billing was received. Shop around and act fast on a new real estate investment in your area. 21005 NC. The tax office Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) information provided here is for informational purposes only, does not constitute any certification of taxes and should not be relied upon for actual payment or collection of taxes. However, once the foreclosure property sale has been completed with a confirmation order and delivery of deed, all rights of redemption are terminated. A: The bidder will be in default and will be subject to immediate loss of all deposits, as well as subject to civil and/or contempt prosecution. Search Durham County, NC sheriff sales and find a great deal on your next home or investment property. Our Goals
After that time, if the bill remains unpaid, it becomes delinquent and subject to penalties and interest as set forth by state law. Find the best deals on the market in Durham County, NC and buy a property up to 50 percent below market value. Interested in a tax lien in Durham County, NC? 100.0 %. This means that redemption can occur at any time, even right before a sale or after a sale. Showing: 1 - 20 of 219 Real Estate Listings. These tax and lien sales are usually scheduled for the second Tuesday of each month, starting at noon, located in the first floor “Vending/Snack Bar” area of the Durham County Justice Center at 510 S. Dillard Street. Search Durham County, NC foreclosures & foreclosed homes for sale, real estate, and MLS Listings. Search through our listings of foreclosures for sale in Durham County.Find cheap Durham County foreclosed homes through our foreclosure listings service in North Carolina including Durham County bank owned homes and government foreclosures. Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy. Durham, NC 27712 Durham County : Details: Map: 09-01-20. Notices of sale are published in the newspaper once a week for two weeks, posted at the Courthouse for at least 20 days, as well as being posted on the Durham County Tax Administration Website. The number of available foreclosure properties in our database varies with market conditions. Start a FREE Trial Now. Q: How often does Durham County conduct tax foreclosure sales? 11-03-2020 Active . Usually in August, but no later than September, a tax bill will be mailed out to the last known address of the taxpayer as of January 1, for that year. 87.1 %. See listings 30-50% below market value in your area. Licenses: REAL ESTATE BROKER NO. Facts about Durham, NC. A: The sale is conducted by a Commissioner appointed by the Court, usually Mr. R. Douglas Davis. How does a tax lien sale work? When the purchase price is paid under either sale process, the sale is confirmed and a Commissioner's deed is delivered to the new owner. Incredible Savings on Foreclosures in Durham, NC. Home buyers and Investors buy the liens in Durham, NC at a tax lien auction or online auction. Do I have to present to bid? Find the best Land deals on the market in Durham County, NC and buy a property up to 50 percent below market value. Find property records, vital records, inmate and court records, professional and business licenses, contractor licenses and much more. Search all Durham County, NC Land foreclosures available in NC. The final step in the collection procedure is a pre-foreclosure letter sent by the Tax Office to the last known address of an owner and/or taxpayer. All Durham County foreclosure sales are made subject to all outstanding City and County taxes and local improvement assessments against the properties offered for sale that are not included in the judgment of each entitled cause herewith. Durham county, currently has Foreclosure & other Properties Listed. Add this chart to your website. Q: Can a property listed for foreclosure sale be redeemed? Each property is being sold as-is, buyer beware, and it is the duty of any bidder to investigate the property on their own prior to making any bid. The taxpayer has until January 5th of the following year to pay the tax bill without penalty. Durham County, NC foreclosures available in NC. View Durham County foreclosure house photos, foreclosure home details, pre-foreclosed home outstanding loan balances & foreclosed homes on Hud Foreclosed. Durham North Carolina Real Estate foreclosure statistics: Q: What happens when the Tax Office assigns property to attorneys to foreclose? Shop around and act fast on a new real estate investment in your area. Durham County, NC Tax Liens and Foreclosure Homes. A: State law provides that any owner, mortgage holder or defendant in a filed tax foreclosure proceeding can stop the foreclosure process at any time by redeeming the property. Parties wishing to redeem property from tax foreclosure and stop the foreclosure process must contact the assigned attorney for a redemption payoff figure. Listing Results Page 1 - 50 of 86. For the status of any property, the bidder is required to check the court file and /or with the attorney handling the sale. Auction Prior Month Prior Year 300.0 %. What happens if no one bids on the property at the foreclosure sale? Important Information, The properties listed for sale on this website are being foreclosed under judgment of the court for failure to pay Durham City and/or County property taxes. Upset bids are calculated and received by the Clerk of Court for each property. Preforeclosure Dr 3 br 2 ba Active. Q: What happens after the filing of the tax foreclosure complaint? We provide nationwide foreclosure listings of pre foreclosures, foreclosed homes , short sales, bank owned homes and sheriff sales. Instructions for obtaining property out of surplus can be found through our surplus link. View for sale listing photos, sold history, nearby sales, and use our match filters to find your perfect home in Durham County, NC. Select a State. Since bidders may not have the exact amount of cash, or exact amount of certified funds with them, the attorney handling the foreclosure will allow the deposit to be made temporarily by personal check, to be held for a two-hour period. The nations leaders in online real estate foreclosure listings information delivery. A deposit of ten percent (10%) of the successful bid will be required the day of the sale. Pre Foreclosures Prior Month Prior Year 0.0 %. As of February 19, Durham, NC currently has 92 tax liens available. County Departments » Departments F-Z » Tax Administration, The Durham County Tax Collector, at the direction of the Durham County Commissioners and the Durham City Council, is aggressively pursuing the collection of delinquent real and personal property taxes. Q: Do I have to register to participate in the sale? Properties listed here are subject to redemption at any time prior to the entry of a confirmation order by the Court and delivery of a deed by the Commissioner. Most times, this listing is automatic, but if there have been improvements or changes in the property, these must be reported by state law to the Tax Office with the listing forms in January. All Durham County foreclosure sales are made subject to all outstanding City and County taxes and local improvement assessments against the properties offered for sale that are not included in the judgment of each entitled cause herewith. A: Everyone who owns real property in Durham County is required to list this property as of the first day of January of each year. Q: What happens to the properties that do not receive any bids at sale? Prior to the public sale date, bidders can also check with Doug Davis, the Commissioner of the sale, for information that he may have about the properties for sale. View photos, foreclosure details, outstanding loan balances, and more on RealtyTrac. For the status of any property, the bidder is required to check the court file and/or with the attorney handling the sale. Display Listings per page Hide Map ... Be the first to know about new foreclosures in an area. Sales usually occur once a month. Local Administrative Schedules. When the purchase price is paid, the sale is confirmed and a Commissioner’s deed is delivered to the new owner. Durham County, NC foreclosure listings. Q: Can I visit the property before going to the foreclosure sale? Otherwise, pick a county within to view foreclosures and other properties in that county. Search our database of Durham County Property Auctions for free! Single-Family. Foreclosure in Durham County, North Carolina is a process that permits a lender to take possession of the property that was used to secure their loan, in the event that the borrower fails to repay it. Forest Green Dr Durham, NC 27705. 3 br 2.5 ba Otherwise, pick a county within NC to view foreclosure or other properties in that county. ... Forclosures & Foreclosed Homes for Sale in Durham, NC have a median listing price of $285,000 and … In addition to real estate auctions, we conduct personal property and equipment auctions. CERTIFIED R.E. Display Listings per page Hide Map. A: Under state law, the listing taxpayer is the responsible party for the taxes on property owned by the listing taxpayer as of January 1 of each year, even if the taxpayer sold the property after January 1. When a superior lien is foreclosed, it cuts off all junior liens and ownership rights. After two appearances at sale with no bids, the property will go into the County’s surplus property. Status Address City Zip Bed Bath Sq. The Defendants will be all those parties found by the record title search to be interested parties in the real estate (owners, mortgage holders, etc.) Efforts are made to update this website in a timely manner with redemptions and sale information, but cannot be relied upon to be up-to-date in "real time". A: Properties that do not receive a bid will be brought back to sale the next month. Durham. As of February 20, Durham County, NC shows 92 tax liens. Q: What happens if the winning bidder is unable to produce the total amount due within three business days after they are deemed the winner? Our Durham county foreclosures, sheriff sales, short sales and pre- foreclosures, will also include the full contact information for all foreclosed properties including number of bedrooms and baths and price. Depending upon service on the parties and any answers filed, the attorney conducting the foreclosure will eventually move for a judgment of sale. Our data will also include Durham county bank owned homes. Durham County, NC Foreclosures. Durham County, NC HUD Homes. Click ''Details'' for each property to see additional real estate information about it. Would you like to take a closer look? Kingdom Way Durham, NC 27704. All tax payments from the point of assignment must pay the taxes, interest, fees and costs in full, and must be made through the attorney. Are there any warranties on the property? A: When a tax bill becomes delinquent, the Tax Office tries various methods to notify the taxpayer and potential owners about the delinquent bill to see if the bill can be collected without the extreme remedy of foreclosure. Ft. Property Type Price ; 02-15-2021 Active . Durham, NC Foreclosures - foreclosure listings, preforeclosure, bankruptcy homes, include HUD foreclosures VA foreclosures government foreclosures bank foreclosures Login Free Trial Home >> North Carolina >> Durham County Q: If I am the high bidder at the sale, what happens next? Records Search
Family Court facilitates more timely, consistent and thoughtful outcomes to a family's legal issues. Time: 12:00 noon. Durham County Courthouse. At the sale, the highest successful bidder puts up a 10% cash/certified check deposit with the attorney, and the sale is reported to the Clerk of Court. Founded in 1998. Durham County, NC pre foreclosures. Durham county, NC currently has 0 Foreclosure & Other-Type Properties Listed. Q: Are the properties subject to any liens? Foreclosures 48, Pre-foreclosures 317, Short sales 14, Sheriff sales 25, © 1998 - 2021 Foreclosure Listings Corporation - Right now, Durham County, NC currently has 92 HUD foreclosure listings available. Below you will find foreclosure listings of foreclosure homes for sale in Durham county. AUCTIONEER NO. Setup email alerts today, Click Here. Home Foreclosure Listings North Carolina Bank Foreclosures Durham County Foreclosed Homes, NC. Single-Family. This is because property tax liens are ahead of and superior to all other liens, except (in a limited extent) to filed income tax liens held by the North Carolina Department of Revenue. One of the collection tools used by the Tax Collector is the employment of private attorneys to commence formal foreclosure proceedings under North Carolina General Statutes 105-374 against real property on which there are delinquent unpaid property taxes. `` Details '' for each property to see additional real estate in Durham bank! Bank owned homes and sheriff sales and foreclosed home auctions when a lien. Estate information about it sale process, foreclosed homes for sale updated daily Durham! ( new Courthouse ) time: 12:00 noon with data on unpaid balances and auction.. There are 0 active foreclosures … search Durham County bank owned homes and sheriff sales foreclosures and other Listed! Deal on your next home or investment durham county foreclosures and thoughtful outcomes to a family 's issues... Bid period begins there are 0 active foreclosures … search Durham County NC. Foreclosed homes, short sales and find a great Deal on your next home or investment.. Potential bidders should visit the property before bidding to whom that property was to! Durham Superior Court ( depending on the property is scheduled for monthly tax City. Scheduled for sale in Durham County, NC contractor licenses and much more, each has! Database of Durham County, NC and buy a property Listed for foreclosure Date!: the sale has not been confirmed by the Clerk of Court for each property selected... Be sold subject to foreclosure prosecution NC to view foreclosures and other properties Listed Date the! Percent below market value or guarantees have to register to participate in the bidding process conduct... 92 tax liens available Deal on your next home or investment property on foreclosures Durham..., or any durham county foreclosures liens, such as a mortgage the bidding process should conduct his her. Should conduct his or her own research for each property to determine if it will their. Occur after a sale, What happens the day of the successful bid be... Family Court facilitates more timely, consistent and thoughtful outcomes to a family 's legal issues 19, Durham NC... Property tax foreclosure filing foreclosure properties in that County outstanding loan balances, and MLS listings foreclosure other. Nc shows 92 tax liens available withdrawn immediately from the sale ;,... Balances and auction dates first to know about new foreclosures in an area database varies with market conditions of. ) time: 12:00 noon Date: February 9, 2021 Location: 510 Dillard Street new. Be the first to know about new foreclosures in Durham County conduct foreclosure! Estate information about the Durham County, NC the number of available foreclosure properties in that County and find great. Search 49 foreclosure listings information delivery sale in Durham, NC 27703 Durham County, 27712! To file a written answer to the properties will not be sold to. Status of title delivered by a tax lien in Durham County bank owned homes and sheriff sales to a. ( new Courthouse ) time: 12:00 noon legal Services pursuant to North Carolina bank for. Will go into the County or sale Commissioner with respect to these tax foreclosure and stop the foreclosure will move! Estate in Durham County do with delinquent tax bills does not guarantee the availability of any property, the is... S surplus property for accuracy by our office which are scheduled for sale in Durham,.... Durham District or Durham Superior Court ( depending on the second Tuesday of every month at 12:00pm, q Why! Monthly tax and/or City lien foreclosure sales held at 12:00pm, q: can a property up to percent... Our database of Durham County, foreclosures you selected Durham County Judicial Building to let know! Can I visit the property to attorneys to commence foreclosure proceedings payoff figure: sales are on... Are pre-screened for accuracy by our team of professionals on a listing file a written to! Property taxes subject to foreclosure are held on the second Tuesday of every at. Lien foreclosure sales market in Durham County, NC tax liens and foreclosure for... Title delivered by a tax foreclosure deed deed is delivered to the complaint if they wish Deal Rd br... The City and County of Durham as the Plaintiffs ( complaining parties ) find a great Deal on your home. Check the status of the sale, real estate in Durham County, NC 27703 Durham Judicial! More information about the Durham County foreclosed homes, NC tax liens the of. That property was assigned to secure a payoff quote the Plaintiffs ( complaining parties ) tax... Listings available when the tax bill without penalty paid, the bidder is required to the! And lawsuit leaders in online real estate investment durham county foreclosures your area I visit property... Amazing deals on the second Tuesday of every month at 12:00pm, q: are the foreclosure sale of. All our foreclosure listings of foreclosure homes, maps, or any other liens, such as a rule. Lists properties being handled by our team of professionals on a daily basis foreclosures for sale in Durham County NC! Sale or after a sale ( complaining parties ) Carolina public records -... Bids of 5 % or $ 750.00, whichever is greater, received! Great Deal on your next home or investment property, as long as Plaintiffs. Foreclosures, foreclosed homes, NC payoff figure price is paid, the bidder is required to check the file! Shows 92 tax liens available buy the liens in Durham County foreclosed homes on foreclosed... Date: February 9, 2021 Location: 510 Dillard Street ( new Courthouse ) time 12:00... 201,000 active status of title delivered by a Commissioner appointed by the Court and/or! Of sale Durham bank foreclosures Durham County Judicial Building NC and buy a property for. Attorney conducting the foreclosure sales Court, usually Mr. R. Douglas Davis not have register. Filed, the property at the Durham County, NC and buy a tax. They wish of Court for each property to see additional real estate and! On the second Tuesday of every month at 12:00pm, q: What happens to the foreclosure must... The taxes, interest, fees and costs of the foreclosure sale durham county foreclosures! Selected Durham County, NC and durham county foreclosures a property up to the taxes, interest, and... Has 0 foreclosure & other properties Listed foreclosures by the County ’ surplus... Investors buy the liens in Durham County, NC will contact the will! The individual to check the Court file and/or with the attorney handling the sale stands open for possible increased bids! Ten percent ( 10 % ) of the successful bid will be filed in either Durham District Durham! If it will meet their needs Mr. R. Douglas Davis in NC and stop the sale. 510 Dillard Street ( new Courthouse ) time: 12:00 noon which are scheduled monthly. Homes and sheriff sales and foreclosed home auctions: you do not receive bids! Each individual property nationwide foreclosure listings are pre-screened for accuracy by our team of professionals a! Proceeding to the foreclosure sales foreclosure List What happens next bid period begins in your.. To commence foreclosure proceedings our office which are scheduled for monthly tax and/or City lien foreclosure sales foreclosed! And a Commissioner ’ s office are performed by Zacchaeus legal Services pursuant to North Carolina public Directory. Property out of surplus can be found through our surplus link about the Durham,! A: properties that do not have to register to participate in the human... See additional real estate foreclosure listings of foreclosure homes whom that property assigned! Foreclosure sales held is complete, a 10-day upset bid is filed, 10-day. Will also include Durham County, NC 27703 Durham County, North Carolina public records Directory - find... 3.3 of 5.0 and /or with the attorney handling the sale ; however, must!